The Protectionism Delusion

Economists through years of study and practice haveeffectively retard international commerce than tariffs.
concluded that through free trade, based on theNon-tariff barriers (NTBs) refer to licensing
principal of comparative advantage, the worldrequirements, unreasonable standards pertaining to
economy can achieve a more efficient allocation ofproduct quality and safety, or unnecessary
resources and a higher level of material well-being. Onbureaucratic red tape in customs procedures. Great
the other hand, protectionism measures-barriers toBritain bars importation of coal this way. Finally,
free trade-lessen or eliminate gains from specialization.voluntary export restrictions (VERs) are a trade
Trying to satisfy diverse wants, nations shiftbarrier by which foreign firms "voluntarily" limit the
resources from efficient (low cost) to inefficient (highamount of their exports to a particular country.
cost) uses. This is the reason why, instead ofBut, when examining protectionism theory exceptions
promoting competition, governments turn up to faceare apparent. Under proper conditions, the
monopolies that harm the economy and do not fulfillinfant-industry argument stands as a valid exception,
the consumers' needs.justifiable on economic grounds. Moreover, on
Furthermore, the costs of protectionism are hiddenpolitical-military grounds, the self-sufficiency argument
because trade barriers are embedded in the prices ofcan be used to validate protection. But both
goods. Thus, either due to misunderstandings of thearguments are susceptible to severe abuses, and
gains of trade or due to political considerations,both neglect other ways of fostering industrial
governments may impose trade barriers, withdevelopment and military self-sufficiency. Most other
consequences such as higher prices, which can not bearguments are semi-emotional appeals; half-truths and
realized by the public at the beginning.fallacies. They see only the immediate and direct
No matter how compelling the logic for free trade,consequences of protective measures, and they tend
barriers do exist. Tariffs are excise taxes onto ignore the fact that in the long run a nation must
imported goods. They may be imposed for purposesimport in order to be able to export.
of revenue or protection. Protective tariffs areIn conclusion, the statement that can illustrate best
designed to shield domestic producers from foreignthe protectionism delusion is that the gains trade
competition. Although they are usually not highbarriers create for protected industries and their
enough to prohibit importation of foreign goods, theyworkers come at the expense of much greater
put foreign producers at a competitive disadvantagelosses for the entire economy. The result is economic
in selling in domestic markets. Import quotas specifyinefficiency. As historical evidence suggests, free
the maximum amounts of commodities, which maytrade has led to prosperity and growth, while
be imported in any period. Thus, they can moreprotectionism has had the opposite effects.