Will the US Suffer an Inflation Or Deflation in 2009-2010 Or Both?

On October 10, 2008, I posited four possiblewell broadcast and has been absorbed by almost all
scenarios regarding the outlook for our generalplayers. The Pound may be oversold.
economic future. Of those four scenarios, it may beSince the dollar is still the world's primary reserve
that we are experiencing the most chaotic andcurrency (though that is in a state of adjustment), it
potentially destructive scenario, one that may beis unlikely at this time that countries such as China
difficult for many to envisage:and Japan who buy our Treasuries and sell us
That is the third outcome posited in the article: "Inmanufactured goods (taking our dollars in return as
this case, the deflationary forces would win theI.O.U's, increasing the supply of dollars outside the
battle against Federal Reserve easing andU.S.), will give up on us completely. However, they
government action, at least temporarily. In responsemay look upon their massive U.S. investments with
to a deflationary calamity, the Federal Reserve maytrepidation as we have lowered our living standards
run the printing presses until an inflationary recoveryby accumulating massive public and private debt
could take place. Gold may do well under this chaoticwhich must now be deleveraged. And there is no
scenario."guarantee that the deleveraging will go smoothly. It
Currently, U.S. consumer demand for goods iscertainly has not up until this point. Our foreign
abetting and consumers are retrenching as a result ofcreditors may shudder when they see us run our
the drying up of the credit spigot. Credit is now onlyprinting presses to stimulate our domestic economic
available to the soundest of borrowers. Money maygrowth, which may turn the current whiff of
not be readily available to many borrowers to buydeflation in our economy into a galloping inflation and
new homes, refrigerators, and automobiles. Thegold price, with double digit interest rates, and may
consequent deleveraging of the average consumerresult in the fall of the dollar in future years. During a
(who is over his head in debt and who cannottime of severe stress on the dollar, the Obama
borrow more to finance purchases) is a powerfuladministration could conceivably restrict the
wave in the U.S. Without the proposed mortgage andmovement of U.S. capital to and from our shores. As
bank bailout by the Obama administration, millionshas happened with nations who have followed such a
more Americans might be on the cusp of losing theirpolicy, our stock market and the dollar might react
homes.badly.
In addition, significant layoffs (from the likes of IBM,On the subject of free trade, should we enact a
Intel, and Macy's) have the potential to lead us into aprotectionist trade policy, such as the trade barriers
downward economic spiral of decreasing demand andenacted in the 1930's, we could see additional
employment. Further, in this economy, we are alsoshuttered storefronts and increases in
experiencing price decreases caused by retailersunemployment, amplifying the current recession.
selling off goods as they liquidate their businesses. InDemand for goods by displaced workers could dry
a normal economy where credit is available, theseup. Given that so many of the goods used in this
retailers might have been able to go into bankruptcycountry have been produced entirely or in part
and then receive financing to operate until theyoutside the U.S., the net effect of increased
emerged out of it, saving valuable jobs.protectionism could be inflationary, reflecting the
Weakened banks are receiving huge cash injectionshigher costs of producing more goods by better paid
of Federal money, turning them into partial wards ofAmerican workers. The big risk is that our tariffs
the State. Tens or hundreds of billions of dollars maymight be reciprocated by our trading partners, which
ultimately be spent by government authorities incould be a real disaster for the world economy.
bailing out the countless owners of three- orA misguided Obama administration might enact strict
four-bedroom houses whose mortgages are underregulations or increase taxes on industries that are
water.currently performing well (at least relatively): the oil
The Federal Reserve under Chairman Bernanke andindustry and the railroads are possible targets. Some
the Obama Administration has used and may utilizesee the railroads as price gougers because they are
further the myriad tools at their disposal to extricatemaking excellent profits on hauling a variety of
our economy from this slump that has showncommodities. And last time I checked, at least one
deflationary characteristics. The Fed can simply printrailroad was hiring. Before they were deregulated in
all the dollars that are necessary to stimulate1980, the rails stagnated for decades and many rail
domestic growth, which in the long run makes thelines were unprofitable. The deregulation allowed the
dollar worth less. The dollar may simply be inflatedindustry to dynamically alter its business: reducing
away, with the current deflation turning into a greatcosts and improving service performance, laying the
inflation in the coming years, damaging the dollar'sfoundation for a deregulation success story.
local and international purchasing power. It may beReregulation may restrict the railroads' profits and
that the "cure" for our disease--massive governmentwould likely lead to more layoffs and cuts in service. I
spending and easy money from the Federalbelieve that under some circumstances, regulation can
Reserve--will be our undoing.be effective, but the problem lies when regulations
In Meltdown: A Free-Market Look at Why the Stockstay on the books for many years or even decades,
Market Collapsed, the Economy Tanked, andhamstringing the industries they were meant to "help"
Government Bailouts Will Make Things Worse,as the old regulations become increasingly obsolete. It
Thomas E. Woods, with foreword by free marketappears to me that more regulation leads to less
thinker Ron Paul, describes the real causes of theoverall potential in the economy and could result
current economic and stock market collapse. Woods,either in inflation or deflation. The case of the
"a senior fellow at the Ludwig von Mises Institute andstruggling airlines is instructive. Prior to deregulation,
winner of the 2006 Templeton Enterprise Award,"airline profits were guaranteed and the public had to
shows how government is not the solution to theswallow the cost. In this instance regulation inflated
current economic crisis, but is actually making theairfares.
slump worse. Buy this one to gain greater insight intoIn conclusion, the deflation of many asset class
today's economic disaster.values and some prices at the retail level that we
A demonstration of how quickly an economy cancurrently see may be followed by a longer period of
change is in the example of the Icelandic financialincreasing price inflation caused by excessive growth
calamity of 2008. As reported on Wikipedia, Iceland'sin the money supply. This scenario could further
three largest banks failed and Iceland's government'sdestabilize our stock market, economy, and our
central bank was not large enough to guarantee thecurrency markets. If the Obama administration makes
banks' bad debts (something that may not happeneconomic policy blunders as I have discussed, many
here: theoretically, our Federal Reserve's balancemarket participants may lose confidence in U.S. policy
sheet is infinite).and continue selling the stock market.
Iceland's stock market fell 90%, the local currencyHowever, if there are limited economic policy
inflation rate rose into double digits and the value ofmistakes, the stock market may find a bottom in
the Icelandic krona sharply declined. Unemployment2009 and may rally powerfully from that trough, and
increased. The savings of many citizens werethen may continue in a trading range (a similar
decimated. The movement of capital to and frompattern occurred in the rally after the nearly 50%
Iceland is permitted only with permission from the1973-1974 decline). Reflation winners who may
authorities. Citizens who hold foreign currencies mustbenefit most from the rally are major oil firms and
hold them in an Icelandic bank. Iceland's transitiongold firms as well as physical gold. Gold is also
from an enviable success story to utter financialinsurance should the unthinkable occur and the
collapse all happened in the span of less than a year.economy melt down into a broad deflation without
Great Britain's government authorities havenear term recovery in sight.
effectively nationalized much of the banking sector inThis article contains the opinions and ideas of its
response to insolvencies among many formerlyauthor and is designed to provide useful general
powerful banking institutions. The British currency hasinformation to the reader on the subject matter
fallen 30% from about $2.00 to $1.40 per Pound. Thecovered. The author may or may not have current
Pound does not have world reserve currency status,positions in the investments mentioned in this work,
which may explain why so many market participantsand the author may from time to time make
are more able to bet against it: it is not widely ownedinvestments in a manner that is not described here.
throughout the world and may be available in thePast investment performance is no guarantee or
scheme of the currency market to be sold heavily.prediction of future results and any investments
Britain is seen as a declining power in the midst ofmade, based on the opinions and ideas contained in
crisis and its currency is merely reflecting this.this work, may or may not be successful. The
However, Britain suffered mightily from thestrategies contained herein may not be suitable for
stagflation years of the mid 1970's, when inflationevery investor or situation, and the author is not
rose to 25%, but its economy was later revived byengaged in, and should not be construed to be,
the free market policies of Margaret Thatcher. So Irendering legal, accounting, investment advisory or
would not count Britain out just yet. Much will dependother professional services to the reader or any
on future U.K. economic policy. That said, I would notother person. Readers should consult their own
be surprised to see a short term rally in the Pound asadvisers for advice particular to their individual
the difficult reality of the current situation has beencircumstances.